Dear Per You have disregarded exchange transactions of the central bank which can also add or drain. These are part of the vertical component (of the very useful vertical-horizontal taxonomy).
I am still at loss as to how you define money (or 'currency' or 'net nominal wealth' if you prefer that).
I see two definitions, both of which are based on how that stuff (which I will keep calling 'money') enters the system: by spending alone or by lending and spending. Clearly for the sake of symmetry, if money is injected only by spending then it must be withdrawn only by taxation (including fees, etc.). Similarly, if money is injected by spending or lending, then it should be withdrawn by taxation or borrowing.
Let's for the sake of the argument call the 'spending only' concept MA, and the 'spending and lending' concept MB. The change by transaction in the amount of money will be given by
\delta MA = Govt Spending - Taxation
\delta MB = (Govt Spending + Govt Lending) - (Taxation + Govt Borrowing)
best wishes bill
------
William F. Mitchell Professor of Economics and Head of Department Director, Centre of Full Employment and Equity University of Newcastle New South Wales, Australia E-mail: ecwfm@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Phone: +61-2 4921 5065 Fax: +61-2 4921 6919 Mobile: 0419 422 410
WWW Home Page: http://econ-www.newcastle.edu.au/economics/bill/billeco.html
- Re: fiscal deficit - Mosler addendum, mosler Tue 27 Nov 2001, 00:31 GMT
- Re: fiscal deficit - Mosler addendum, Per Gunnar Berglund Tue 27 Nov 2001, 02:08 GMT
- Re: fiscal deficit - Mosler addendum, Warren Mosler Tue 27 Nov 2001, 19:00 GMT
- Re: fiscal deficit - Mosler addendum, Per Gunnar Berglund Wed 28 Nov 2001, 00:05 GMT
- Re: fiscal deficit - Mosler addendum, Bill Mitchell Wed 28 Nov 2001, 01:50 GMT
- Re: fiscal deficit - Mosler addendum, Per Gunnar Berglund Wed 28 Nov 2001, 20:24 GMT
- Re: fiscal deficit - Mosler addendum, Warren Mosler Wed 28 Nov 2001, 02:43 GMT
- Re: fiscal deficit - Mosler addendum, Per Gunnar Berglund Wed 28 Nov 2001, 21:28 GMT
- <Possible follow-up(s)>
- Re: fiscal deficit - Mosler addendum, William B. Ryan Tue 27 Nov 2001, 04:46 GMT