PEN-L
mailing list archive

Other Periods  | Other mailing lists  | Search  ]

Date:  [ Previous  | Next  ]      Thread:  [ Previous  | Next  ]      Index:  [ Author  | Date  | Thread  ]

Re: Failure of socialist revolution in the West is fault of Kremlin



The Great Russian chauvinism went hand in hand with hostility to gay rights, feminism, experimentalism in the arts, workers democracy and every other emancipatory impulse in the USSR. Stalin was transmitting the social pressure of Czarist officialdom, which was re-emerging in the 1920s in the vacuum created by the civil war, and a general rightward climate brought on by imperialism and the failure to make socialist revolution in the West--a failure in itself directly attributable to the Kremlin's own lack of Marxist insights.<
 
Comment
 
Social Revolution in the West . . . do this include England, the American Union and South America and say Mexico?  I know "the West" generally does not include say Japan . . . or the so-called Middle East or Africa.
 
"the failure to make socialist revolution in the West . . . directly attributable to the Kremlin's . . .  "  is the repudiation of history and common sense.
 
This is what is being stated. The failure of socialist revolution in the American union in 1920 is attributable to the Kremlin.
 
The failure of socialist revolution in the American union in 1930 is attributable to the Kremlin. The failure of socialist revolution in the American union in 1940 is attributable to the Kremlin. The failure of socialist revolution in the American union in 1950 is attributable to the Kremlin. The failure of socialist revolution in the American union in 1960 is attributable to the Kremlin. The failure of socialist revolution in the American union in 1970 is attributable to the Kremlin. The failure of socialist revolution in the American union in 1980 is attributable to the Kremlin. The failure of socialist revolution in the American union in 1990 is attributable to the Kremlin. The failure of socialist revolution in the American union in 2004 is attributable to the Kremlin.
 
Pardon . . . directly attributable to the Kremlin.
 
Not just the failure of socialist revolution in America but all of the West is DIRECTLY attributable to the Kremlin. Now this failure of socialist revolution in the West . . . which is DIRECTLY ATTRIBUTABLE TO THE KREMLIN ... occurred because of a lack of MARXIST INSIGHT.
 
The diverse peoples of America wanted a socialist revolution and their striving was defeated as the direct result of the Kremlin.
 
Nay . . . the peoples of the West . . . this includes Mexico and South America and England and Ireland ... wanted a socialist revolution and their striving was defeated as the direct result of the Kremlin.
 
If one allow Mr. P to rant long enough all of his rank Great American chauvinism and anti-Russianism . . . which is disguised as anti-Stalinism . . . comes spewing out.
 
There is . . . let me guess . . . a "dialectical connection" between Gay Rights in the Soviet Union and the failure of Socialist Revolution not just in America, Mexico, Argentina, England, Ireland and the rest of the West . . .  that is directly attributable to the Kremlin.
 
The failure of socialist revolution in America is not directly attributable to any economic, social or political factors in America or the White House . . . but the Kremlin.
 
Every generation of communist in American history has had to confront the institutionalized spilt in our working class that took the form of the segregation of the African American and the most brutal and violenct forms of white chauvanism in the Western world . . . but this has not been the fundamental ideological impediment to socialist revolution . . . but rather the Kremlin's lack of Marxist insight and "hostility to gay rights, feminism, experimentalism in the arts, workers democracy and every other emancipatory impulse in the USSR."
 
I call this kind of thinking what it is . . . rotten white chauvinism and an affront to the battered proletarian masses in American history.
 
During the 1920's and the period that birth the Red Summers as a mass orgy of hangings, lynching's and bombings of African Americans . . . yes bombings . . . is swept under the rug to covered the criminal contempt of murderers and jackals of imperial capital . . . and the failure of socialist revolution is attributable to the Kremlin.
 
Man . . . you need to be cool . . . and not let everyone know you are the anti Russian rotten chauvinist that you are . . . trying to dictate to the world's people about what they should do to be free as you pound away on keyboard in the most imperial of all imperial centers.
 
What a lack of common sense.
 
You are saying that the failure of socialist revolution in the West . . . America and 90 years of brutal segregation is directly attributable to the Kremlin and not the contempt that the Anglo American people have poured on the African American masses for the better part of a century . . . and this is connected to the lack of Gay Rights and experimental art in the freaking Soviet Union.  
 
You are a rank chauvinist of the worst kind. 
 
Let me guess . . . me being an unreconstructed Stalinist . . .  (your direct characterization) . . . do not understand what "directly attributable" means.  
 
The failure of socialist revolution in Mexico and Puerto Rico is directly attributable to the Kremlin and bad Marxists ideas in the Kremlin. Is the Philippines part of the West? Is Haiti part of the West?
 
What . . . here is the "comrade" who has written and cried crocodile tears over the Kremlin banning the European foreign language presses in the American Union and demanding that the communists in America conduct their propaganda in the basic language of 90% of the people in America . . . English and Spanish.
 
I swear!
 
The Anglo American (white) workers have nothing to do with the failure of socialist revolution in the West and America . . . along with the deep conservatism of the African American masses and other historical factors. Rather the fault is ... ta da . . .  Stalin and the Kremlin. Why? Because Trotsky said Thermidor.
 
You should be ashamed.
 
 
Melvin P.


Other Periods  | Other mailing lists  | Search  ]