PEN-L
mailing list archive

Other Periods  | Other mailing lists  | Search  ]

Date:  [ Previous  | Next  ]      Thread:  [ Previous  | Next  ]      Index:  [ Author  | Date  | Thread  ]

Re: Swedes less well off than poorest Americans -study




See the following website for some relevant critical comments about this presumptively dubious study. I tried to get a copy of the study to check for myself, but HUI's website is very uncooperative.

http://www.surfacecity.net/

Gil



http://biz.yahoo.com/rf/020504/sweden_poverty_1.html

Swedes less well off than poorest  Americans -study

STOCKHOLM, May 4 (Reuters) - Swedes,  usually perceived in Europe as a
comfortable, middle class lot, are  poorer than African Americans, the  most
economically deprived group in the  United States, a Swedish study  showed on
Saturday.


The study by a retail trade lobby, published in the liberal Dagens Nyheter newspaper 19 weeks before the next general election, echoed the centre- right opposition's criticism of the weak state of Sweden's economy after decades of almost uninterrupted Social Democratic rule.

The Swedish Research Institute of  Trade (HUI) said it had compared  official
U.S. and Swedish statistics on  household income as well as gross  domestic
product, private consumption and  retail spending per capita between  1980 and
1999.

Using fixed prices and purchasing  power parity adjusted data, the  median
household income in Sweden at the end  of the 1990s was the equivalent of
$26,800 compared with a median of  $39,400 for U.S. households, HUI's  study
showed.

"Weak growth means that Sweden has  lost greatly in prosperity compared  with
the United States," HUI's President  Fredrik Bergstrom and chief  economist
Robert Gidehag said.

International Monetary Fund data from  2001 show that U.S. GDP per capita  in
dollar terms was 56 percent higher  than in Sweden while in 1980,  Swedish GDP
per capita was 20 percent higher.

"Black people, who have the lowest  income in the United States, now  have a
higher standard of living than an  ordinary Swedish household," the HUI
economists said.

If Sweden were a U.S. state, it would  be the poorest measured by household
gross income before taxes, Bergstrom  and Gidehag said.

They said they had chosen that  measure for their comparison to get  around
the differences in taxation and  welfare structures. Capital gains  such as
income from securities were not  included.

AMERICANS CAN BUY MORE

The median income of African American  households was about 70 percent of  the
median for all U.S. households while  Swedish households earned 68 percent  of
the overall U.S. median level.

This meant that Swedes stood "below  groups which in the Swedish debate  are
usually regarded as poor and losers  in the American economy," Bergstrom  and
Gidehag said.

Between 1980 and 1999, the gross  income of Sweden's poorest  households
increased by just over six percent  while the poorest in the United  States
enjoyed a three times higher  increase, HUI said.

If the trend persists, "things that  are commonplace in the United States
will be regarded as the utmost luxury  in Sweden," the authors said. "We  are
not quite there yet but the trend is  clear."

According to HUI figures, in 1998-99  U.S. GDP per capita was 40 percent
higher than in Sweden while U.S.  private consumption and retail sales  per
capita exceeded Swedish levels by  more than 80 percent.

The HUI economists attributed the  much bigger difference in  consumption and
sales mainly to the fact that U.S.  households pay themselves for  education
and health care, services which are  tax-financed and come for free or at  low
user charges in Sweden.

According to recent opinion polls  Sweden's Social Democrats are  comfortably
ahead of the centre-right opposition  in the run-up to the September 15
elections.




Other Periods  | Other mailing lists  | Search  ]