Re: Re: Re: Re: RE: Re: : Premises, Circularities

[phillp2@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx]

Hey, I think this debate is great.  I can delete the whole day's
posts without reading them and think of the time I save ;-).

Paul Phillips,
Economics,
University of Manitoba

> Doug wrote:
>
> > As is always the case with these debates,
> > I can't resist the urge to ask - so what?
> > Why is the value controversy so important?
> > Why is it so important for Justin to reject
> > it and Rakesh to defend it?
>
> This is highly correlated with the question I was asking to
> myself Doug: What is the purpose of this debate?
>