Nathan writes:Questions raised are whether there are ways to better encorporate such qualitative measures into state planning. I would argue that without democracy as an alternative "feedback" loop to the market, undemocratic state planning must by nature ultimately fail.
well phrased! BTW, Trotsky made a similar point after he'd been kicked out of power.
Jim Devine
I like political democracy rather more than the next guy/gal (on this list, at least). But it isn't the key to the riddle of history...
http://www.nps.gov/malu/documents/jim_crow_laws.htm
Brad DeLong
- capitalist versus socialist progress, (continued)
- capitalist versus socialist progress, Louis Proyect Sun 13 Feb 2000, 16:15 GMT
- RE: capitalist versus socialist progress, Nathan Newman Sun 13 Feb 2000, 19:42 GMT
- Re: RE: capitalist versus socialist progress, Jim Devine Sun 13 Feb 2000, 21:21 GMT
- Re: Re: RE: capitalist versus socialist progress, Brad De Long Mon 14 Feb 2000, 04:53 GMT
- Re: Re: RE: capitalist versus socialist progress, Brad De Long Mon 14 Feb 2000, 04:55 GMT
- RE: capitalist versus socialist progress, Nathan Newman Mon 14 Feb 2000, 06:08 GMT
- Re: RE: capitalist versus socialist progress, Michael Perelman Sun 13 Feb 2000, 21:33 GMT
- RE: Re: RE: capitalist versus socialist progress, Nathan Newman Sun 13 Feb 2000, 22:25 GMT
- Re: RE: capitalist versus socialist progress, Brad De Long Mon 14 Feb 2000, 04:52 GMT