[PEN-L:1994] Re: Something completely different

[glevy@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx]

Louis N Proyect wrote:

> Louis: Jerry's reply to Shawgi is an example of the kind of discourse you
> can't get away with on the Marxism list. It is dripping with professorial
> condescension. All Jerry needs to do is give Shawgi a grade (B-, C+?). If
> you deconstruct the message, what you come away with is the notion that
> Shawgi's ideas are not "serious" because in the past, he has recommended
> some writings or another by Stalin or Hoxha.
--------
What Louis fails to mention is that *HE* said basically the same thing to
Shawgi just a few days ago on the marxism list. Mr. Bunny, it seems, has
a short memory (Louis: try eating some carrots). If anyone is interested,
check the marxism archives.

I will not attempt to "grade" Shawgi's posts. If someone is interested, I
suggest that you check the marxism archives and "grade" those posts for
yourself.

Jerry