Re: (OPE-L) Ernesto's "Damned Lies" ?

[Ernesto Screpanti <screpanti@xxxxxxxx>]

Dear Jerry and Phil,


I am very much interested in knowing what I said; and also Kliman's 
"Lies, Damned Lies, and
Screpanti's Critique of Marx". I take it to be an
honour to be in disagreement with Kliman.

Is it possible to have a copy, possibly by attachment, of both
"my" paper and Kliman's?

In solidarity

Ernesto




At 02.23 15/02/2004 +0000, you wrote:
> > The
> > program for the upcoming EEA conference in Washington, D.C.
> > is posted at:
> > http://www.iona.edu/academic/arts_sci/orgs/eea/conf2004/cover.htm
> >  
> > In Session 55, sponsored by the IWGVT:
> > http://www.iona.edu/eea/conf2004/Fri2pm.htm
> >  
> > there is a paper to be presented on: "Lies,
> > Damned Lies, and
> > Screpanti's Critique of Marx".
> >  
> > What articles or books by Ernesto is he alleged to have been
> > lying
> > about Marx?
> >  
> > In solidarity, Jerry
> >  
>
> Hi Jerry
>
> There was a conference in Rome last year,  organised, I think, 
> by Laboratorio per la Critical Sociale.  Ernesto Screpanti's paper
> was entitled 'Value and Exploitation: A Counterfactual Approach'. 
> >From the first paragraph:
>
> .. Cavallaro's appeal to beware of mystifying labour values lets us hope
> that the search can proceed along correct lines today, avoiding certain
> scholastic forcings which we have witnessed in the past, although the
> interventions of Carchedi, Freeman and Kliman seem to want to kill this
> hope at birth.
>
> This could well elicit a response.
>
> I have a hardcopy. I will bring it to Washington.
>
> Phil