[Marxism] Revealing Newsweek article on Hizbullah

[Louis Proyect <lnp3@xxxxxxxxx>]

(Christopher Dickey, one of the authors of this most interesting article, 
is a fine reporter. His book on the Nicaraguan contras was top-notch.)

Newsweek: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/14208385/

Eye For an Eye
Israel shadow-boxes with a surprisingly high-tech foe. Inside the new 
Hizbullah.
By Kevin Peraino, Babak Dehghanpisheh and Christopher Dickey

Aug. 14, 2006 issue - Hizbullah's fighters were as elusive last week as 
they were deadly. Thousands of them were dug in around southern Lebanon, 
and yet encounters with the hundreds of journalists also in the area were 
rare, and furtive. Like Hussein, as he chose to call himself, who popped 
out of the rubble in the blasted town of Bint Jbeil, site of what Hizbullah 
is calling its Great Victory, to crow a little. He was in civvies, the only 
way the Hizbullah fighters appear in public, but the walkie-talkie under 
his loose shirt was a giveaway. The hillside nearby glittered with metal in 
the bright sun. Here and there lay shell casings, mortar tubes, mangled 
shrapnel from artillery and bombs. Thousands of cartridges, the gold ones 
from Israeli M-16s, the duller brown from Hizbullah's AK-47s, all mixed 
together. This was asymmetrical warfare with a fearful symmetry. Hussein 
picked up a handful of empty brass. "Very close-range fighting," he said, 
jingling them in his palm. "You can imagine what weapons we have and what 
weapons they have."

In an olive grove about five miles away, it wasn't necessary to imagine. 
Under camo netting, half-covered with the broad-leafed branches of a fig 
tree, was a GMC truck with a rocket-launching platform, probably for the 
122mm Katyusha, fired wildly into Israel. It was untouched, unlike its twin 
a football field away, which lay mangled in an Israeli counterstrike. There 
was no sign of Hizbullah fighters, though, and locals spoke of seeing 
little kids running like mad from the rocket batteries after they fired. In 
Khiam, a teenager on a motor scooter rolled through town, apparently 
minding his own business?except that the ear bud of the walkie-talkie 
hidden under his shirt identified him as one of Hizbullah's many scouts. 
They were hard to find?until they wanted to be found.

Hizbullah is proving to be something altogether new, an Arab guerrilla army 
with sophisticated weaponry and remarkable discipline. Its soldiers have 
the jihadist rhetoric of fighting to the death, but wear body armor and use 
satcoms to coordinate their attacks. Their tactics may be from Che, but 
their arms are from Iran, and not just AK-47s and RPGs. They've reportedly 
destroyed three of Israel's advanced Merkava tanks with wire-guided 
missiles and powerful mines, crippled an Israeli warship with a 
surface-to-sea missile, sent up drones on reconnaissance missions, 
implanted listening devices along the border and set up their ambushes 
using night-vision goggles.

NEWSWEEK has learned from a source briefed in recent weeks by Israel's top 
leaders and military brass that Hizbullah even managed to eavesdrop 
successfully on Israel's military communications as its Lebanese incursion 
began. When Lt. Eli Kahn, commander of an elite Israeli parachutists 
outfit, turned a corner in the southern Lebanese village of Maroun al-Ras 
early in the month-old war, he came face to face with this new enemy. "He 
had sophisticated equipment like mine and looked more like a commando," he 
recalled. Lieutenant Kahn ducked back around the corner and reached for a 
grenade, but before he could pull the pin, the Hizbullah fighter had tossed 
one around the corner himself. The Israeli picked it up and threw it back, 
just in time. "They didn't retreat," says Danny Yatom, a former director of 
the Mossad. "They continued to fight until the death."

That combination of modern lethality and Old World fanaticism has taken a 
deadly toll. By the end of last week, 45 Israeli soldiers had died, and as 
many as 250 Hizbullah fighters had perished. Thirty-three Israeli civilians 
had been killed in the rocket barrages, while more than 480 Lebanese had 
died. But Hizbullah was boasting of its success. As Israel continued to 
push its ground offensive, progress was painfully slow, one small Lebanese 
village at a time.

Diplomacy was stalled, too, despite agreement on a U.N. ceasefire 
resolution expected to pass early this week. By Saturday the Israeli 
Defense Forces, with six brigades?close to 7,000 soldiers?could claim only 
to have subdued half a dozen villages, a long way from their goal of 
establishing a secure buffer zone, possibly as far north as the Litani River.

Israel's cabinet approved the ground campaign after its air war had failed 
to suppress Hizbullah's fire. On Wednesday the Israelis declared they'd 
destroyed two thirds of Hizbullah's missile arsenal, but on Thursday 
Hizbullah launched more than 200, with almost as many on Friday. Hizbullah 
leader Hassan Nasrallah vowed to strike Tel Aviv if Israel bombed Beirut 
again, and some thought he might be able to.

The whole calculus of this sort of warfare has changed, as even the 
Israelis gave grudging high marks to their opponents. The sort of weaponry 
Hizbullah is deploying is normally associated with a state, and states can 
be easily deterred by a superior military force like Israel's. They have 
cities to protect, vital infrastructure. Hizbullah depends to some extent 
on supplies coming from Iran via Damascus, and last week Israel bombed the 
last roads from Syria into its neighbor. But the organization is believed 
to have laid in supplies for at least another month, and when it suits, the 
Hizbullah fighters can disappear into the population. "We live on onions 
and tomatoes," said Hussein in Bint Jbeil, as he pulled one off a vine in 
an abandoned garden.

Last week, when Sheik Ahmed Murad, a Hizbullah spokesman, showed up at the 
Tyre Hospital to rant against the civilian casualties Israel had inflicted, 
he was in his Shiite cleric's turban and robes. After the press conference, 
Murad was escorted away by three bodyguards, then reappeared on the street 
in untucked shirt and slacks, apparently just another civilian. "Their 
strategy is a strategy of disappearance," says one Israeli military 
official, who spoke on condition of anonymity because he was talking about 
operations. "They are well prepared for this kind of invasion. [But] we are 
much stronger than them. We can bring a much greater force than they can 
deal with."

But the Hizbullah guerrillas are well aware of that, too, and they know how 
averse the Israeli military and public have always been to taking 
casualties. "The strategy is to make them lose as many [soldiers] as 
possible," said Hussein, on the cartridge-strewn hillside at Bint Jbeil. 
"Israel doesn't care about the [loss of a] tank. They care about the people."

As the prospect of a quick victory faded from Israeli view, Israel's 
military tried to regain the initiative, raiding a Hizbullah safe house in 
Tyre on Saturday, killing at least three militants in a ferocious 
shoot-out. Earlier in the week it took five Hizbullah prisoners in a raid 
on a hospital in Baalbek, in Hizbullah's Bekaa Valley heartland. "It was an 
attempt to re-create the days of Entebbe," said a senior Israeli security 
source who is not authorized to speak on the record.

How did Hizbullah morph from its terrorist roots 20 years ago to the 
formidably organized force of today? The short answer is: experience, 
leadership and Iran. The group was first pulled together in 1982 by members 
of Ayatollah Khomeini's Revolutionary Guards as a way to spread Tehran's 
influence while fighting against Israeli forces that had laid siege to 
Beirut. The following year the organization became infamous for the suicide 
bombing of the U.S. Marine Barracks in Beirut that cost 241 Americans their 
lives, and a simultaneous attack on French forces that killed 56. Soon, 
Hizbullah added airline hijackings and the taking of American and European 
hostages to its repertoire.

In 1992, Israeli helicopters blew up the then leader of Hizbullah, Abbas 
al-Musawi, along with his wife and son. His successor was Hassan Nasrallah, 
who set a new course for the organization. Under Nasrallah, the militia 
grew quickly into the single most disciplined and powerful political force 
in the country. It built schools, hospitals, provided social services and 
got its members elected to Parliament. At the same time, its soldiers honed 
their skills at guerrilla warfare battling against Israeli troops still 
occupying southern Lebanon, studying their tactics, learning their weak points.

All this cost money, but there was plenty to be had. By Israeli estimates 
Iran has underwritten Hizbullah with $100 million a year. But Hizbullah 
also gets contributions and "tax" payments from wealthy Shiites in Lebanon 
and abroad, and revenues from both legal and illegal businesses worldwide. 
According to a recent study by terrorism expert Magnus Ranstorp at the 
Swedish National Defense College, its shopping list included night-vision 
goggles, Global Positioning Systems, advanced software for aircraft design, 
stun guns, nitrogen cutters, naval equipment, laser range finders and even 
ultrasonic dog repellers.

Over the years, Nasrallah has dressed like a cleric, but talked like a 
clear-eyed politician, reciting facts that suited him, cracking jokes and 
vowing to keep his promises. Cool and charismatic, he broadcast his message 
not only to all of Lebanon, but to much of the Arab and Muslim world over 
Hizbullah's Al-Manar satellite television station. The organization's 
purpose, Nasrallah said, was to fight Israeli occupation. When that ended 
with an Israeli pullout from South Lebanon in 2000, he argued that 
Hizbullah must keep its arms and build up its arsenal. The reason: 
"deterrence."

The effects of Hizbullah's buildup were a dismaying surprise to the 
Israelis from almost the first day of fighting, when Israel launched a 
massive retaliation for a Hizbullah raid across the border that had cost 
them eight soldiers killed and two captured. "The Iranians invested far 
more than people thought," said the source, who had been briefed by 
Israel's most senior leaders. "The command and control centers were state 
of the art. They built a whole network of underground tunnels that enabled 
them to trap Israeli soldiers ... They were eavesdropping on Israeli 
military communications with the equipment they received."

Hizbullah's high-tech communications heighten its classic advantage as a 
guerrilla force fighting on home turf. "The plan was to go deep, but we 
didn't finish it," said 19-year-old Nahum Fowler, a corporal in Israel's 
Nahal Brigade who fought in South Lebanon last week. "They know what 
they're doing. They know their villages really well." His unit never saw 
the enemy, he said. "We mostly heard them."

A diplomatic end to the fighting may be just as hard to find as Hizbullah's 
rocket launchers. By last weekend the French and Americans finally agreed 
on a draft U.N. Security Council resolution calling for "a full cessation 
of hostilities." But diplomats cautioned this is the beginning of a 
process, not the end of it. Hizbullah quickly said it would keep fighting 
as long as Israeli troops were left on Lebanese territory. And Israeli 
Ambassador to Washington Daniel Ayalon told NEWSWEEK on Saturday that 
Israel expects Hizbullah to do more now than just hold its fire. "What is 
important to us is not just that Hizbullah's operations end but also the 
arms shipments from Iran and Syria. And first they must release the two 
abducted soldiers." In that case, countries like France and Italy would be 
reluctant to honor pledges to send peacekeeping troops. "An international 
force arriving in Lebanon without the war having been stopped ... would be 
exposed to Iraq-style risks," said Italian Foreign Minister Massimo 
D'Alema. Worse, they would be up against Hizbullah.

With Richard Wolffe, Michael Hirsh, Dan Ephron and John Barry in Washington 
and Matthew Kalman in Jerusalem

EDITOR'S NOTE: The death toll rose still further as this week began, with 
the deadliest Hizbullah rocket attack yet killing 11 people?nine of them 
reported to be Israeli military reservists?in northern Israel on Sunday. 
Israeli strikes killed at least 17 in southern Lebanon on the same day.


________________________________________________
YOU MUST clip all extraneous text before replying to a message.
Send list submissions to: Marxism@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Set your options at: http://lists.econ.utah.edu/mailman/listinfo/marxism