[Marxism] On Joseph Weydemeyer's rank....

["Charles Brown" <cbrown@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

 Mark L.
Just to clarify.....

Weydemeyer wasn't just "one rank below Grant."

^^^
CB; That depends on whether he was a Major General or not. Grant was a
Lieutenant General (three stars). I got the claim that Weydemeyer was a
Major General from
mes Jackson in a pamphlet "Karl Marx and the United States" (International
1983) says

"Among Lincoln's generals who distinguished themselves was Major General
Joseph Weydemeyer. This close friend of Marx and his best correspondent in
America had been a Prussian military officer. He brought his advanced
military knowledge and experience to the Union armed forces. Also, there was
General August Willich, who had had experience and training as an officer in
the Prussian Army, and like Weydemeyer had first become acquainted with Marx
in the Communist League in Brussels. These men, and many others who served
in the Civil War against the slavemasters' Confederacy, were all veterans of
athe 1848 Revolution in Germany (and other European countries). An
outstanding political leader among themn ws Frederich Sorge... He headed the
First International  when it moved its headquarters to New York in 1872."



  Weydemeyer enlisted as a captain, I believe, but quickly became a
Lieutenant Colonel in the First Missouri Light Artillery.  On September 17,
1864, he enlisted as a
Colonel to raise and command the Forty-First Missouri.  In fact, I'm not
sure that this wasn't actually his highest wartime rank.

In March 1865 and after the Civil War was over, a lot of officers were given
promotions to a "brevet" rank, which supposedly reflected the level of
duties they were actually performing.  A lot these were
postdated, but I don't think Weydemeyer's was higher than
Brigadier-General, but I don't have the biography of Weydemeyer right next
to me.

If you're interested, go to a library.  Don't trust the "Germans Gone
Wild" website on the internet.

^^^^^^
CB: Actually, I have a copy of Weydemeyer's biography myself. Can go to my
own library. I'll be digging it up.

The other post of letter from Engels to Weydemeyer on cannons is from a
Marx-Engels archive. I don't know whether you consider Marx and Engels as
"Germans gone wild".

^^^^^

As to the cannons, the passage isn't at all "ambiguous."  And the idea that
Engels was a broker for the Prussian monarchy's sale of its used cannon to
Weydemeyer as the Red purchasing agent for the U.S. government, it
is...well, nonsensical is as good a word as any.

^^^^^
CB: Not at all nonsensical, as any sensible reader can tell. Starting to
think you protest too much.

Why exactly wouldn't Engels broker such a deal ? He was a cotton
manufacturer during slavery, so it's not like he didn't do commerce with
reactionaries. The sentence is ambiguous. If it not, its unambiguous meaning
would be against your interpretation.

Here's the sentence:

Engels to Weydemeyer: "You may have any number of Prussian
howitzers, as they have all been withdrawn now and replaced by rifled
6-pounders and 4-pounders (which fire 13-pound and 9-pound heavy shells). "

If I say to you "you may have x", one grammatical meaning of this in English
is that "I will sell you x" or "I can help you buy or get x".  Could mean "I
know somebody else who will sell you." That would be the ambiguity. In both
cases, Weydemeyer is possibly getting Prussian howitzers.

What we don't know is whether Weydemeyer actually got them.




August Willich

WlLLICH, August, born in Gorzyn, in the Prussian province of Posen, in 1810;
died in St. Mary's, Mercer County, Ohio, 23 January, 1878. His father, a
captain of hussars during the Napoleonic wars, died when August was three
years old. With an elder brother, the boy found a home in the family of
Frieda rich Schleiermacher, the famous theologian, whose wife was a distant
relative. He received a military education at Potsdam and Berlin, and at
eighteen years of age was commissioned 2d lieutenant of artillery in the
Prussian army, becoming a captain in 1841. In 1846, in company with a number
of the younger and more ardent officers of his brigade, he became so imbued
with republican ideas that he tendered his resignation from the army in a
letter written in such terms that, instead of its being accepted, he was
arrested and tried by a court-martial. By some means he was acquitted, and
afterward was permitted to resign. When the great revolution of 1848
threatened the overthrow of all European monarchies, Willich, with several
former army friends, among whom were Franz Sigel, Friederich K. P. Hecker,
Louis Blenkel, and Carl Schurz, went to Baden and took an active part in the
armed attempt to revolutionize Germany. After its failure, Willich and many
of his con patriots became exiles, he escaped to Switzerland, but afterward
made his way to England, where several of his fellow-exiles had also found
refuge. Here he remained till 1853, devoting much of his time and labor to
aid in his distressed countrymen to reach the United States. He had learned
the trade of a carpenter while in England, and so earned a livelihood.
Coming to the United States in 1855, he first found employment at his trade
in the navy-yard at Brooklyn. Here his attainments in mathematics and other
scientific studies were soon discovered, and he found more congenial work in
the coast survey. In 1858 he was induced to go to Cincinnati as editor of
the "German Republican," in which work he continued till the opening of the
civil war in 1861. He enlisted, at the first call to arms, in the 1st German
(afterward 9th Ohio) regiment, which within three days mustered about 1,500
men. He was at once appointed adjutant, and, on 28 May, commissioned major.
This regiment afterward became one of the best in the service. In the autumn
of 1861 Governor Oliver P. Morton, of Indiana, who was raising a German
regiment in that state, commissioned him as its colonel. This was the 32d
Indiana infantry, famous in the Army of the Cumberland for its drill and
discipline, as well as for its gallantry in action. Willich devoted himself
to this regiment, and with such good results that, on 26 November, 1861,
three companies, deployed as skirmishers, repelled in confusion a regiment
of Texan rangers. This affair gave it a prestige that it retained to the end
of the war. On 17 July, 1862, he was appointed brigadier-general of
volunteers. At the battle of Stone River, 31 December, 1862, he was captured
almost before the action began, and was held a prisoner for several months.
He was exchanged in season to take part, at the head of his brigade, in the
battle of Chickamauga, 19 and 20 September, 1863, and from that time on he
shared in all the movements and battles of the army, including the Atlanta
campaign and the march to the sea and through the Carolinas. He was made
brevet major-general, 21 October, 1865, and was mustered out of service, 15
January, 1866. On his return to Cincinnati he was chosen county auditor,
which post he held for three years. He was visiting his old home in Germany
at the beginning of the Franco-Prussian war, and at once offered his
services to the king, whom he had before attempted to dethrone. His offer
was gratefully acknowledged, but, on account of his advanced age, it was not
accepted. He found consolation, if not more congenial occupation, in
attending lectures on philosophy at Berlin. Returning to the United States,
he chose St. Mary's, Ohio, as his residence.

Edited Appletons Encyclopedia, Copyright C 2001 VirtualologyTM






________________________________________________
YOU MUST clip all extraneous text before replying to a message.
Send list submissions to: Marxism@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Set your options at: http://lists.econ.utah.edu/mailman/listinfo/marxism