Re: [Marxism] Spiked-online token Marxist weighs in on imperialism

[mds <zenporcupinegrind@xxxxxxxxxxx>]

Louis,

On Thursday, September 2, 2004, at 04:33  pm, Louis Proyect wrote:
> Is this the same Frank Furedi who wrote this in his campus faculty
> newsletter [...]

Allegedly.

> Btw, aren't you aware that many ex-RCP'ers have taken corporate
> consulting jobs? One has even morphed into a "terrorism expert" who
> speaks on the same panel discussions as members of the British
> security apparatus, as Phil Ferguson (a former sympathizer of the RCP)
> discovered [...]

I suggest you re-read my comment.

Instead of espousing overly generalised character attacks on anything
remotely LM or RCP related, might I suggest that a concrete analysis of
the material in question is a far more progressive, and less spurious
path to undertake? It's not even as if JH's article says anything
wildly controversial - the impression I get from your approach is that,
had this essay have been posted on _anything-but-spiked.com_, your
rancour wouldn't have been released quite so readily, if at all.

I note your reply merely targets names, not analyses.

-Marc

 __________________________________________________
M. D. Simpson
zenporcupinegrind <at> breathe <dot> com

"Whoever worships the accomplished fact is incapable of preparing the
future."
_______________________________________________
Marxism mailing list
Marxism@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
http://lists.econ.utah.edu/mailman/listinfo/marxism