Re: Recognition of governments (was:: A Russian view of the war (April6)

To: marxism@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Subject: Re: Recognition of governments (was:: A Russian view of the war (April6)
From: "Einde O'Callaghan" <einde.ocallaghan@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Date: Mon, 07 Apr 2003 08:05:03 +0200

"Henry C.K. Liu" wrote:
>
> Correction:
>
> Your view is that of Wolfowitz.
>
I'm sorry, I find your reply to Tom O'Lincoln unworthy of this list. It
is quite possible to be critical of Saddam Hussein and not build him up
into a socialist hero while still opposing the war stropngly, as Tom
O'Lincoln has repeatedly shown.

Your reply is simply a polemical cheap shot. Using such methods you
could also convict Marx or engels or Lenin of being pro-capitalist,
because they spoke of teh progeressive role of capitalism.

Einde

Follow-Ups:
- Re: Recognition of governments (was:: A Russian view of the war (April6)
  - From: Henry C.K. Liu

References:
- Re: Recognition of governments (was:: A Russian view of the war (April6)
  - From: Tom O'Lincoln
- Re: Recognition of governments (was:: A Russian view of the war (April6)
  - From: Henry C.K. Liu
- Re: Recognition of governments (was:: A Russian view of the war (April6)
  - From: Henry C.K. Liu

Prev by Date: Re: How to approach the troops?
Next by Date: Re: uncomradely debate
Previous by thread: Re: Recognition of governments (was:: A Russian view of the war (April6)
Next by thread: Re: Recognition of governments (was:: A Russian view of the war (April6)
Index(es):
- Date
- Thread

Thread context:
- US troops invading Baghdad right now, John Paramo Mon 07 Apr 2003, 05:47 GMT
- Re: Recognition of governments (was:: A Russian view of the war (April6), Tom O'Lincoln Mon 07 Apr 2003, 03:02 GMT
  - Re: Recognition of governments (was:: A Russian view of the war (April6), Henry C.K. Liu Mon 07 Apr 2003, 03:12 GMT
    - Re: Recognition of governments (was:: A Russian view of the war (April6), Henry C.K. Liu Mon 07 Apr 2003, 05:50 GMT
      
      Re: Recognition of governments (was:: A Russian view of the war (April6), Einde O'Callaghan Mon 07 Apr 2003, 15:23 GMT
      
      Re: Recognition of governments (was:: A Russian view of the war (April6), Henry C.K. Liu Mon 07 Apr 2003, 15:47 GMT
  - <Possible follow-up(s)>
  - Re: Recognition of governments (was:: A Russian view of the war (April6), Tom O'Lincoln Mon 07 Apr 2003, 06:05 GMT
    - Re: Recognition of governments (was:: A Russian view of the war (April6), Henry C.K. Liu Mon 07 Apr 2003, 06:29 GMT
  - Re: Recognition of governments (was:: A Russian view of the war (April6), MARIPOWER716 Mon 07 Apr 2003, 08:01 GMT

[ Other Periods | Other mailing lists | Search ]