Marxism
mailing list archive
[ Other Periods
| Other mailing lists
| Search
]
Date:
[ Previous
| Next
]
Thread:
[ Previous
| Next
]
Index:
[ Author
| Date
| Thread
]
Re: Alcohol as a revolutionary weapon?
- Subject: Re: Alcohol as a revolutionary weapon?
- From: Brian James <hillbily@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Sat, 16 Dec 2000 17:04:25 -0800
>Alcohol has long been regarded as a social leveller, and the act of
>communal drinking as a means of communication between those of different
>ranks and status in society. If, as we propose above, the drinking-place
>embodies the symbolic social functions of alcohol, we would therefore
>expect to find, in most cultures, that drinking-places tend to perform a
>socially integrative, equalising function. We would expect drinking-places
>to be, if not strictly egalitarian, at least environments in which the
>prevailing social order may be challenged.
>Full article at: http://www.sirc.org/publik/drinking6.html
This is a very interesting topic, though I see some obvious flaws with
it. First of all the situation described in the article sounds more like
alcohol and pub culture as a means of reconciling the classes and
creating acceptance of the status quo. The working class does indeed
meet in bars, but political talk usually doesn't get beyond drunk talk.
Also there's the destructive role that alcohol plays among the working
class, as described so vividly in the novels of Emile Zola for example.
On the other hand, what role has alcohol played throughout history at
specific points within a revolutionary struggle? I know anarchists like
to use the slogan "booze up and riot." And it seems that whenever
anarchist youth in Montreal go on a rampage, smashing corporate windows
and setting cop cars ablaze, alcohol definitely plays a role.
But alcohol is apolitical. It can be used to embolden any kind of angry
mob. What do the history profs have to say on this?
Brian James
- Thread context:
- Belated,
Charles Brown Fri 15 Dec 2000, 15:40 GMT
- Nation Magazine: "This is no time for a honeymoon",
Louis Proyect Fri 15 Dec 2000, 14:46 GMT
- Eric Foner on the Supreme Court,
Louis Proyect Fri 15 Dec 2000, 14:44 GMT
- Alcohol as a revolutionary weapon?,
Louis Proyect Fri 15 Dec 2000, 14:39 GMT
- Protests,
Charles Brown Fri 15 Dec 2000, 14:35 GMT
- Forwarded from Anthony (follow-up to Yoshie),
Louis Proyect Fri 15 Dec 2000, 14:29 GMT
- Forwarded from Anthony (response to Gary),
Louis Proyect Fri 15 Dec 2000, 14:29 GMT
- Democracy American Style (La Monde diplomatique),
Jay Moore Fri 15 Dec 2000, 13:12 GMT
[ Other Periods
| Other mailing lists
| Search
]