Re: Kosovo and "the Jewish Question"

[Michael Yates <mikey+@xxxxxxxxxxxx>]

This article is problematic, not in terms of the analysis of Kosovo and
Yugoslavia but in terms of the author's condemnation of all ethnic
nationalism.  What would he say about radical black nationalism or the
struggles of indigenous peoples for self determination?

Michael Yates

Louis Proyect wrote:
>
> MONTHLY REVIEW, February 2000
>
> From Kosovo and "the Jewish Question"
>
> by John Rosenthal
>
> THE TROUBLE WITH "MINORITY RIGHTS"
>
> If not, then, the victims or targets of a genocidal policy on the part of
> the Yugoslav state, were the Kosovo Albanians subjected to a process of
> political and civil exclusion analogous to that to which the German Jews
> were subjected by the German State in the Third Reich? Here again, the
> facts?and now we are dealing with straightforward institutional facts which
> are easily verifiable by anyone?simply do not support such a conclusion.
snip