Re: When is a workers' state no longer a workers' state?

[malecki@xxxxxxxxxx (Robert Malecki)]

>I say, old stick, your prose is impenetrable. The question you are
>addressing is an interesting one, but you have to learn how to
>communicate. I have not seen so much jargon strung together in my entire
>lifetime. As a rule of thumb, you should attempt to repackage your ideas
>in language that would be understood by your family over a holiday dinner.
>Thank of what Aunt Rose would make of "logically excludes the reality of
>state capitalism from the transition process." She would probably choke on
>her baked ham.

As usual our hero of the Sandinistas has nothing to say. He uses his sharp
wit to accuse the various Trotskyist currents on this list as using old
"jargon"along with some synical bullshit. Louis your "learning how to
communicate" failed the test miserably in Nicarugua. Because in fact it was
nothing new.

Some come down off your high horse and admit it.

malecki




     --- from list marxism@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx ---