Re: State capitalism?

[Adam Rose <adam@xxxxxxxx>]

Louis writes:
> On Tue, 18 Jun 1996, Adam Rose wrote:
>
> >
> > I would argue that three states, Egypt, Algeria and Cuba do have a lot
> > in common.
>
> Louis: Adam as a zoologist: "Yes, of course, a bear and a
> gorilla are the same. They are both covered with fur, walk about on their
> hind legs often, growl loudly and will give you a nasty bite if you go too
> close."
>

No, they're both Elephants. They're grey and have long trunks. However,
the African Elelphant has big ears and the Indian one has small ears.

> This "state capitalism" theory allows people to avoid the sticky details
> of class analysis. No need to delve too deeply into the relationship
> between the old colonial state and the new administration of the FLN. No
> need to examine the role of French capital within Algeria after the
> colonists were defeated. No need to study the transformation of the
> Algerian bourgeoisie from precolonial to postcolonial periods.
>
> That's okay. I wouldn't expect anything different from him at this point.
> As for me, I've been vexed by this question for some years now and plan to
> take a closer look at Algeria. I'll report my findings which I promise you
> will be informative as usual.
>

Everyone will now politely applaud Louis' superior knowledge.

Do you not think the common elements I pointed out existed in the four
countries : India,Egypt,Algeria,Cuba ?

1. Revolutions, led by sections of the middle class.
2. Working class prevented from playing leading role by Stalinist CP's.
3. State plays a central role in production after revolution.

Adam.



Adam Rose
SWP
Manchester
UK


---------------------------------------------------------------


     --- from list marxism@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx ---