Re: "Transitional states"

["Karl Carlile" <joseph@xxxxxxxxx>]

> Date:          Fri, 7 Jun 96 14:15:23 GMT
> From:          Adam Rose <adam@xxxxxxxx>
> To:            marxism@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
> Subject:       Re: "Transitional states"
> Reply-to:      marxism@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

> >
> > Karl: If there there never was workers state in Russia even immediately
> > after October 1917 then one can conclude that the Bolshevik party never
> > established a workers' state. Adam you have, I as understand it, gone
> > many steps further than the SWP(UK) in your revisonism. Perhaps, secretly,
> > this is the position of the SWP on revolution in Russia and you are now
> > letting us in on the secret.
> >
>
> Get a grip. Read what I said.
> I was talking about the GDR etc , not Russia, when I said there never was a
> workers state. I made this VERY clear.

Karl: Adam would you please forward me a copy of the message on which I based
my response to you.

                              Karl Carlile


     --- from list marxism@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx ---