Malacki-ism/ The wages system under new management

[neil <74742.1651@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Dear robert,

You don't seem to understand what capitalism or socialism really is.
You seem wedded to that old bankrupt social democrat reform view that it
is mere nationalization of industry by the state.
Your  concepts of workers states would include not only ex-Russia
E. Europe state caps but also Sweden, Israel, Spain, England,
Germany, Italy which also have nationalized many industries (to save
 the industries for revamped capitalist profits while paying
the capitalists to sit on their fat arses and lord it over the workers.)
You love the wages system , but you just think it needs new management-
that is why your trend tails behind stalinist states and the trojan
horse union apparatus of labor aristocrats in the west.

Your think you represent bolsheviks but your apologetics are
 bullshittricks!
Like today ,will you define and explain what is the ECONOMIC BASE of
No. Korea , Vietnam, China, Cuba, Laos, etc.  please??
Marxists put forward a scientific one, is it communal, slave, fuedal,
or capitalist , worker controlled transition to socialist society??
Your previuos concepts have been more like the bourgeois university
 political science Depts.
I want your view on the ECONOMY Robert. Then we can turn to dealing
 with the political political superstructure.

Socialism means SOCIALIZATION of productive bourg. property
moving to abolish wage labor exploitation, money, borders
commodity production, market relations and the state machine. Now
I realize this cannot be done in isolation but needs a series
of proletarian revolutions.
But to do this the working class with its future mass economic (rev.
 workers councils, soviets, mass assemblies, committees) and rev.
 political parties  needs to move fast to get rid of capitalist
social relations to advance toward a rationally planned society to
serve human needs and ending sale and profit.

Your neo-spartaco trend seems to oppose all this, you seem to always back
up the state capitalists everywhere. You have NO critique of the wages
system. NO critique of a money economy and commodity production. You
seem to desire ony "restrictions" of the laws of the marketplace so
your stalinist  workers states capital can survive in it which
recent history has already proven utopian. You don't like the more brutal
stalinist state machines, you prefer your neo-spartaco type state machine
which in practice , considering your support for stalinist economy could
at best end up Stalinism-Lite.
This is why your trend ends up with such bizarre formulations when these
states face off against other  imperialist capitals.
Nonsense such as "we give military support but NO political support"
as if a real marxist ever separates the two!!
What, are you spartacos shipping guns or soldiers to the combattants??

Then your trend serves up more bourgeois prattle saying that "the
stalinists are not a ruling CLASS , only a conservative caste"
Really Robert. How do you have a political state and no ruling classes
in it?
Finally your trend says the law of value is inoperative in stalinists
 states and the workers are not exploited economically!! Ridiculous
Even the stalinist economists are more honest than you today and
they admit that the law of value  plays a big part in the determination
of their state cap. plans.
This is one of the reasons your ex "ruling caste" today had the material
basis to emerge out of the state cap collapse to become powerful
"Beeeznezzmen" in the  capitalist exploieter regimes in E. Europe
and Russia today!

Malecki, your jig is up. Start analyzing the world of today and
stop your boring bible thumping of trotskys works from 6-7 decades
ago. Even Mr. Trotsky hearing your twaddle today would ,to paraphrase
 Marx,  say "if this is marxism than I am not a Marxist."
You could become more than a legend in your own Mind.

NC


     --- from list marxism@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx ---