RI: TROTSKYISM SINCE WWII

[luigi.candreva@xxxxxxxxx (Luigi Candreva)]

LNP3@xxxxxxxxxxxx hai scritto alle 15:44:09:



 LN> If Adolfo speaks mostly about Peru, what else would you
 LN>  expect? What I would expect from other people is
 LN> probing analysis of the  class-struggle in their own
 LN> countries. The 1920s and 1930s are over. We have  to
 LN> provide leadership for the working-class today, not the
 LN> working-class of  yesteryear.

     This is really not true. Adolpho spoke a lot about
Indonesia, rise of fascism in Italy, accusing people (like
you) to have been "morally acomplices" of Sukharno and
Pinochet, and to being fascists (long posts on how fascism
arose from socialdemocracy). This kind of bullshit I cannot
tolerate in the "marxism" list. And you challenged him on Red
Referendum, and so on (by the way, your posts on that?). After
that I exposed all his lies and slanders, he turned speaking
only about Peru, saying that the rest were "things of the
past". After that sir (given that he doesn't like to be called
comrade by European communists) Adolfo has lost his battle
with the arms of the critique, he turned up to the workers
battaillons that the Pcp is leading in Peru. And I didn't say
anything about Peru, also because, BTW, here I collaborate on
the same paper with a comrade which has a Centre of
documentation on Latin America, and is very simpathetic with
the Pcp. That's also the reason why I treated sir Adolfo in a
civil way, and also because I wanted to expose all his
political vacuum, without going in a flame war.

     I already heard during my political activity that the
past times are "over" (normally this kind of think come from
union and party bureaucrats that don't like to speak about
their treasons). I could offer you a lot of sentences on
"learning from the past" an so on... I give you only one, that
parties without a past have no future. And Adolfo didn't say
simply that the past is over, but that Stalin was right to
kill trotskists and other revolutionaries: with a past like
that, you imagine which future? History is not on our back, it
is before us, comrade Louis (probably you will accept to be
called comrade).

Luigi

 --- MMMR v4.50reg



     --- from list marxism@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx ---