Re: Ralph Dumain and the SWP

[iwp.ilo@xxxxxxxxxxxxx (CEP )]

You(Ralph Dumain) wrote:

Never have I been in favor of cynicism.
>But I do know something from everyday expereince just how bad things
are,
>and I have to engage real people as they exist in this society, not
>ultraleft sectarian jackoffs.

   Carlos:

    Dear Ralph:

    My posting was neither a joke nor a sarcasm.  I put that warning
    on top of my posting but, somehow, appeared on the To: line.

    RALPH:

  You are not even capable of arguing with
>JUan about Argentina, which is your own turf.  are you going to
>argue with me about the USA?

    cARLOS:

    I wasn't even dreaming in arguing with you, less of all about the
    US.  BTW, I think that at the very end of the scale, you and Juan
    are one and the same.  The only difference is that he thought like
    you in the seventies and because he was like you refused to act
    when the shit hit the fan.  He survived because of that.  I'm sure
    is very painful for him, too.

    Ralph:

  Are you giong to argue about the
>severity of alienation of the masses from the means ofproduction
>and the administation of society?  Sad sad sad indeed.

    Carlos:

    I was actually agreeing with that aspect of your post.  If you
    ask me again, I will repeat it: "His logic is impenetrable"

    And yes, is sad, indeed.

    Carlos





     --- from list marxism@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx ---

     ------------------