Re: Kamenevy

[iwp.ilo@xxxxxxxxxxxxx (CEP )]

You(Matt Dillon) wrote:
>
>Taking a break from his usual expletive-laden frenzy, Carlos writes:
>
>>    Sure, we know.  Do You?  The tell me, Scotty, why is that the
>>    Communist Party, USA *never* discuss Trotsky, Zinoviev, Kamenev
>>    and other brilliant Bolsheviks?
>
>Kamenev was a brilliant Bolshevik?!  Please elaborate.  Or perhaps you
are
>using the word "brilliant" in an idiosyncratic fashion?
>
    Carlos:

    I Have no idea what idiosyncratic fashion means .... but, anyway.
    Kamenev was a member of the central Committee of the BNolsheviks
    and one of the architects of the urban party development in the
    pre and post Russian revolution periods.

    He oppossed the insurrection, collaborated briefly with Stalin
    during the Troika period, belonged to the Unified Opposition,
    then switched again to the right but he cannot ultimately stomach
    Stalinism and died because of that.

    In spite the fact that he oposed the insurrection and broke
    discipline, when insurrection was launched he disciplined again to
    the party and carried many tasks to secure the victory of the
    1917 revolution.  Was an excellent writer, a very capable party
    organizer and an excelent educational director of the Bolshevik
    party.

    Do I agree with him politically?  Not at all.  But he was brilliant
    in coparison with present day communist leaders and many who claim
    to be bolsheviks.  He also have a beautiful wife who served the
    revolution extremely well. Or you believe that he was also a Nazi
    spy?

    Matt wrote:
>Also, why do you refer to Scott as "Scotty"?  Do you feel that is
helpful,
>conducive to further conversation?
>
    Carlos:

    Conducive conversation with somebody who defend the rump gang
    formed by Godenas and Quispe? Who utter insults and distortions
    about things he have no idea about, like Trotsky's writtings and
    political positions?

    I call him Scotty as reminiscence of "Beep me up Scotty ...". I
    would like him to beep me up to his highs as  aleader of the now
    mass CPUSA.

    Now, for somebody like you criticizing me about this is really
    funny. But doesn't matter.  I can handle.






     --- from list marxism@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx ---

     ------------------