Re: Stalin, Mao, idealism and voluntarism

[glevy@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx]

MIM3 wrote:

  Would you care to take
> responsibility for what would have happened in the
> Soviet Union if it had followed France's or Romania's
> methods of dealing with World War II?

A truly *stupid* question. When did I ever suggest that the USSR should
follow "France's or Romania's methods of dealing with World War II"?

> But at least you admit you prefer the status quo.

When did I admit this?

 You'd rather the millions starve to death than
> engage in war and the dictatorship that goes with it.

More distortions.

> Next I will post something we have already done debunking
> some anti-Stalin trash. It's a taste of what can be found
> in our theory journals, which anyone can have all 8 of for
> $25 sent to MIM PO Box 3576, Ann Arbor, MI 48106-3576

Yeah, I can see list members sending in their checks now.

Pat, I've tried to be nice. I started by asking you reasonable questions
which you have mostly ignored. Since you continue to distort the
positions of others and make excuses for the murder of millions, I will
delete your messages unread in the future. I've got better uses of my
time than to waste it debating ignorant and irrelevant sectarians.

Jerry


     --- from list marxism@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx ---

     ------------------