Re: Who we are/How we write

[glevy@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx]

This is the third re-write of this post. I want to zero in on just one issue:

Juan Inigo wrote:
>
> According to Jerry's abstraction, the development of the proletariat's
> conscious action is not produced _by_ the proletariat itself, but _for_ the
> proletariat by some enlightened declassed intellectuals alien to it! Quite
> far from Marx, and quite close to the Catholic Church, that claims that
> "people" must do things _for_ the poor.

Wherever did you get the above from? It certainly wasn't my post.

> If Jerry's national narrowness (that makes him suggest as a natural thing
> that I visit a place located in the hemisphere opposite to where I live)

Please explain how the suggestion that you visit factories in the "Illinois
Class  War Zone" was an example of my "national narrowness."

I was very tempted to respond to Juan's post with stronger words.

Jerry


     --- from list marxism@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx ---

     ------------------