Re: Productive and Unproductive Labor

[glevy@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx]

  Paul Z.
  -------

> E-mail messaging is sometimes difficult since the potential for a quick
> response to a potential misinterpretation is unavailable.

  Jerry
  -----

  I agree with you on the above point. I am impressed with the fact that
  all of the participants in this thread have shown that we can discuss
  theoretical issues with each other in good faith. It is not often that
  Marxist economists can get together, discuss an issue, and agree
  that some formulations and ideas are better than others.  We might not
  be agreeing on all points, but we are at least making an honest effort to
  understand each other.  It is a very good sign for our list.

  We do not agree, though, on our interpretations of productive and
  unproductive labor. Your ideas on state production, state capitalism,
  and the importance of the "production and reproduction of human
  life" concept to the distinction between productive and unproductive labor,
  are different from my own. That is OK. Simply referring to what Marx
  wrote on this subject does not resolve this debate.  Surely, we have to
  look at what Marx wrote critically. We will probably not agree, but, if
  we can continue to develop our ideas through explanation and really
  listen to other perspectives, then we will all benefit.


     --- from list marxism@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx ---

     ------------------