Re: BHA: Book notice: Creaven, Marxism and Ralism

["Andrew Brown" <Andrew@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Hi Mervyn,

Very briefly:
Your accusation that Creaven is 'purely dogmatic' etc. re God
seems unfortunate and ill considered to me. You in fact go on to
contradict yourself by going on to consider the *arguments*
Creaven makes for his position. Dogmatists don't make arguments
they make dogmatic assertions. You disagree with the argument:
fair enough. But obviously mere disagreement doesn't justify
labelling those with whom you disagree 'dogmatists'. (A term I
particularly dislike for some reason).

Best wishes,
Andy


     --- from list bhaskar@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx ---