A-list
mailing list archive

Other Periods  | Other mailing lists  | Search  ]

Date:  [ Previous  | Next  ]      Thread:  [ Previous  | Next  ]      Index:  [ Author  | Date  | Thread  ]

Re: [A-List] Re: Yasmin Amin on Mubarak and Al Azhar



The statement that Islam is basicly a religion of the middle way,
deeply humble (I add), deeply tolerant...That is what the man who
wrote "The Golden Bough" about all the world's religions,stated about
it....he wrote in Queen Victoria's time ...before the systematic
demonisation ... is a healingly welcome comment in this powerful
philosophy of belief..

On 3/19/07, CeJ <jannuzi@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
cutting to the crux of the matter:

>>What I find very puzzling is that the government clamps down so very
hard on Islamists and Muslim Brothers, yet allows their constant
meddling in intellectual affairs. This is very strange, because it is
exactly this intellectual backwardness disguised as religious zeal,
which is the core challenge to Mubarak's ostensibly secular state. In
the Human Rights Watch report of 2005 it was noted: "The Egyptian
government must create an environment where academic freedom is
respected, i.e., restore autonomy to the universities and cease
violating the rights of individual members of the community. Such
steps would make it harder for those who challenge academic freedom to
achieve their goals. The state should also actively oppose intolerant
individuals or groups who carry out attacks against academic freedom.
For example, it should reject calls to censor books and allow students
to choose their own thesis topics. Rather than combating Islamists'
attempts to limit academic freedom, Egypt has allowed them to deprive
others of their rights.">>

Ahhhh....bourgeois academics--conformists without a cause. The issue
isn't really academic freedom but rather freedom of speech for all.
The government wants to control Islamists as well as bourgeois
academics, and has found one means in the rectorship of Al-Azhar. How
strange is that? Not very.

CJ






Other Periods  | Other mailing lists  | Search  ]